Notes on unpublishing, corrections and delisting
These unpublishing notes follow the detail that a single request never shows: how a newsroom words its corrections policy, what a search engine's removal tool does and does not clear, and how courts have ruled on old stories. For a walk through one kind of page, the topics are the better starting point.
Recent entries in the notebook
- The notebook is open at a blank pageNo notes have been published yet. In the meantime, the section on where the right to erasure stops covers the question we are asked most.
What is the notebook for?
A topic page tells you who to write to. The notebook is for the questions that come up once you have written: why the editor answered as she did, what the form meant by a phrase, whether the result you can still see in search is a refusal or only a delay.
The notes fall into four kinds.
- Policies, read closely. Newspapers, broadcasters and platforms publish rules on corrections, anonymity and removal, and they revise them. A note takes one policy, quotes the operative lines and says what a request under it should contain.
- Tools, tested against their own help pages. Search engines offer several removal tools with similar names and different effects. Google's Refresh Outdated Content tool, for instance, is meant for a page its publisher has already removed or changed while the search listing still shows the old version, and it is no use against a page that is still live and unchanged.
- Law, kept in proportion. Erasure rights, defamation and copyright each reach some pages and not others. A note explains one rule, cites the text and says where it stops.
- Terms, used precisely. Unpublishing, retraction, correction, clarification, anonymisation, de-indexing and delisting are different acts with different consequences. A sound request often fails because it asked for the wrong one of these.
Our house rules fit in a paragraph. Each statement about a publisher, a platform, a regulator or a court is drawn from that body's own page and linked. Where we could not confirm a detail at its source, it is left out, however often it is repeated elsewhere. Each note is dated, and a note that has been overtaken by a policy change is corrected in place with the change marked, which is no more than we ask of the publishers we write to.
You will not find case stories here, or tallies of pages removed. Outcomes belong to the editors, moderators, reviewers and judges who decide them, and one person's result predicts little about another's. You will also not find methods for forcing a page down. The notebook covers requests made openly, through channels the recipient provides.
The notebook is independent commentary. It is not issued by, and does not speak for, any publisher, platform, search engine or court it discusses, and it is not legal advice.